QB's 2009

So one of the things that needed fixing once I resurrected this blog was the QB ratings - going into this season here are how I see them. The first number is meant to be the value to the team - contribution to winning - the second is a more subjective estimate of how valuable the QB might be to a fantasy owner - some interesting differences...

1. Brady-1
2. Brees-2
3. Palmer-3
4. Rivers-5
5. P. Manning-4
6. Rothlesburger-10
7. Warner-6
8. Hasslebeck-7
9. Cutler-8
10. Farve-12
11. Flacco-13
12. Cassell-9
13. Pennington-11
14. Orton-12
15. Quinn-10
16. Eli Manning
17. Edwards
18. Collins
19. Girard
20. Garcia